Bake Shop
At Mary Kelley’s Bake Shop you're sure to find a sweet treat to calm your sweet tooth. Perfect for any occasion...big or small.
Our desserts are made fresh daily and are available for order. We recommend you call ahead to reserve your special treat.
Our "Whole" Desserts
Apple Pie...$15.00
Cheesecake...$45.00
Cherry Pie...$15.00
Chocolate Cream Pie...$15.00
Coconut Cream Pie...$15.00
A Cream Puff at Mary Kelley’s:
"It’s huge, anyone can afford it, and it satisfies a seasonal lust for pastry-encased custard.”
-The Columbus Dispatch
Banana Cream Pie...$15.00
Pecan Pie...$16.00
Pumpkin Cheesecake...$45.00
Pumpkin Pie...$10.00
*Restaurant sized Whipped Cream...$4.00
CALL AND ORDER YOURS TODAY 614.760.7041
Desserts by the slice are also available to take home.
Coconut Cream Pie:
We're famous for our Coconut Cream Pie
The Shoppes of Athenry, 7148 Muirfield Drive, Dublin, OH 43017 PH: 614.760.7041 Site Design by Gable Creative & Design.
